Cervical Instability w/ Chiari II Surgery Doesn't Cause Problems

January 31st, 2009 -- As part of most decompression surgeries for Chiari, surgeons will remove part of one or more bony vertebral segments of the spine; the procedure is called a laminectomy. In general, a surgeon will remove bone from the segments which are pressing on the herniated brain tissue. Therefore, while many laminectomies only involve the first segment (C1), a large herniation may require a more extensive laminectomy.

Unfortunately, as bone is removed from more segments, there is a downside. Specifically, surgeons begin to worry about creating instability in the spine, which would need to be corrected through fusion. In a large review of syringomyelia patients, Batzdorf showed that laminectomies beyond C1 can lead to spinal problems. Other research has shown that children may be at risk for developing instability associated with laminectomies. (Note that this is different than the work out of the Chiari Institute, which has shown that a subset of Chiari patients may fail with decompression surgery alone, due to connective tissue issues, and require cervical fusion for stability.)

Given these findings, it would seem logical that children with Chiari II would be at a high risk for cervical instability following Chiari decompression. This is because many patients with Chiari II (which is associated with spina bifida and can involve extensive herniations), undergo surgery as children and require laminectomies well beyond C1 (Figure 1).

Figure 1: MRI of Child With Chiari II to C4 Level


However, in a study published in the January, 2009 issue of the journal, Child's Nervous System, a group of Canadian researchers show that the risk to Chiari II patients may actually depend on how you define instability. Specifically, the authors reviewed the medical records of children seen at their Spina Bifida clinic, who had undergone multi-segment laminectomies to treat Chiari II.

They identified nine such children, five boys and four girls. Their average age at the time of surgery was 2 years, and the laminectomies averaged an extensive 4.6 vertebral segments. The post surgical x-rays were examined for signs of instability with the neck bent forward (flexion) and backwards (extension).

Figure 2: Radiographic Measurements of Instability


The researches used generally accepted numerical measurements of distances and angles to determine if there was cervical instability (Figure 2). Using this criteria, they found that 5 out of 9 of the children showed cervical instability on the x-rays (Figure 3).

Figure 3: X-ray of Child With Post-Op Cervical Instability


However, none of the children - even with instability on x-rays - showed any clinical signs or symptoms of instability. None of the children suffered from neck pain or neurological deficits commonly associated with spinal instability, and perhaps most important, none required surgical fusion to correct the instability (Figure 4).

Although in one sense this result is surprising, it does support earlier research. Specifically, one study found that 19 out of 20 children with extensive laminectomies showed radiographic signs of instability, but none required surgical correction. Given these findings, the authors speculate as to whether the radiographic definition of instability is even meaningful. When reading this, one can not help but think of the similarities to the radiographic definition of Chiari (at least 3mm-5mm) and how it too has been shown to be of limited value.

While this research is good news for Chiari II patients and their families, it is difficult to extend these findings to the general Chiari population. Beyond the very small number of patients involved, it is important to note that many of these children are limited in their activities due to spina bifida and their reduced activity level may be one reason that signs and symptoms of cervical instability have not emerged.

Figure 4: Characteristics of Chiari II Patients (9 Total)

Patient Level of Laminect. X-ray Instability Clinical Instab.
1 C1-3 Y N
2 C1-3 Y N
3 C1-4 N N
4 C1-7 N N
5 C1-6 Y N
6 C1-4 N N
7 C1-3 Y N
8 C1-6 N N
9 C1-5 Y N

Notes: Level of laminectomy refers to the vertebral segments in the cervical region

Related C&S News Articles:

Cervical Fusion In Chiari Patients

Surgery Has No Effect On Cervical Range Of Motion

Extensive Laminectomy May Increase Risk For Spinal Problems

Surgical Technique Alleviates Serious Complication After Decompression