Decompression Before Scoliosis Surgery?

As reported previously by this publication, the relationship between Chiari, syringomyelia, and scoliosis is complex and not well understood (see Related Stories). MRI's have shown that a significant number of so-called idiopathic scoliosis cases actually involve some form Chiari or syringomyelia, but the exact link between the conditions is not yet known. Despite this, doctors and researchers have made progress in understanding the practical implications of this complicated relationship.

Recently, researchers have proposed different models for when someone with scoliosis should have an MRI to look for Chiari. Others have shown that treating the underlying Chiari or syringomyelia can actually stop the progression of the scoliosis in some cases. On the flip-side, it is becoming all too clear that performing spinal surgery to correct scoliosis without first treating an active syrinx can be very risky. In fact, some studies have shown that up to 1/3 of such surgeries can lead to worsening, or permanent, neurological problems.

To complicate matters, the increased use of MRI's in scoliosis cases has led to the discovery of otherwise asymptomatic Chiari and SM. In such cases, where scoliosis is the only real symptom of an MRI identified Chiari or syrinx, the question becomes is decompression surgery really necessary before a spinal correction surgery to treat the scoliosis?

Dr. Masatoshi Inoue, an orthopedic surgeon, and his colleagues at Chiba University, in Japan, set out to answer this question, and identify the prevalence of CM/SM in idiopathic scoliosis, by prospectively studying 250 children they treated between 1998-2001. They published their results in the January 1, 2005 issue of the journal Spine.

The patient group consisted of 207 girls and 43 boys. The average age when they were first seen was 12 years, and the average age at surgery was 15 Two patients had infant scoliosis, 72 had juvenile, and 176 had adolescent. Each patient had a severe enough curve(s) to warrant surgical intervention.

Every child underwent an MRI and neurological exams. The MRI's revealed an abnormality in 44 of the children (18%) [see Table1]. Twenty-two children had Chiari with syringomyelia, 13 had just Chiari, 6 had tonsillar ectopia, and two had tonsillar ectopia with syringomyelia [Ed. Note: demonstrating that defining Chiari and tonsillar ectopia in this way is not really necessary].

Table 1
Abnormal MRI Findings, Neurological Exam Findings & Surgery

Finding # of Patients
Chiari w/syrinx 22
Chiari 13
Tonsillar Ectopia 6
Ectopia w/syrinx 2
Other 1
Total 44
Abnormal Neurological Exam Findings 26
Normal Neurological Exam 18
Decompression + scoliosis surgery 12
Scoliosis Surgery 32

Notes: Chiari defined as herniation greater than 5mm; tonsillar ectopia as herniation between 1mm-5mm

In addition, there were significant differences between the children with MRI findings and the children without. Specifically, being younger than 11 at first visit, a left-sided curvature, a thoracic kyphosis of more than 30 degrees, neurological deficits, and moderate/severe pain, all were related to finding CM, SM, or tonsillar ectopia upon MRI.

A similar number of the children, 46 (18%), were found to have abnormal neurological findings upon physical examination. However, only 26 of this group also had an abnormal MRI finding. This means that 18 children showed Chiari or SM on MRI, but had no neurological signs or symptoms, including 4 with both CM and SM. Of the 26 who had both MRI and neurological exam findings, 12 underwent decompression surgery before spinal surgery. These children were selected based on the MRI findings plus severe pain (headache, back pain, or limb pain), abnormal reflexes, motor weakness, or sensory deficits. None of the 12 experienced any problems during the subsequent spinal surgery to treat their scoliosis.

Dr. Inoue and his group were most interested in seeing how the remaining 32 children with MRI diagnosed CM or SM did during surgery to treat their scoliosis. During the procedure, their neurological status was monitored and they were given thorough neurological exams after the surgery. As Dr. Inoue hypothesized, none of the 32 children experienced any problems during the surgery, or had any permanent neurological problems as a result of the surgery.

While the risks of spinal surgery in the presence of untreated Chiari and syringomyelia are well documented, Dr. Inoue and his group appear to have identified a more precise criteria for when decompression surgery is necessary before scoliosis surgery. If further research proves them to be correct, then their model might spare some children unnecessary surgery when there are no neurological signs or symptoms.


Related C&S News Articles:

Linking Chiari, Idiopathic Scoliosis, And Genetics

Study Identifies Types Of Scoliosis That Indicate Chiari

Chiari, Syringomyelia, Scoliosis, and Surgery.

How to treat syringomyelia related scoliosis in children.